Today I did a presentation at work that I was not at all confident about. It should not have been a big deal - it is just an internal conference for all the PhD students in our institute, and we each have a chance to showcase our work. Yes there are two experts who review the text we each had to submit a few weeks back, and yes they give you some feedback, but we are allowed to present "work-in-progress" so it is perfectly normal for the outcome to be, "you need to work on this a lot more". But still, I was stressed out yesterday and today. Normally doing presentations does not make me nervous (in fact it is normally the opposite - I enjoy them and often feel energized during and after), but this time round, I felt under prepared and anxious.
Back track to a few weeks ago... For this event, called Doctoriales, we each had to submit an abstract at the beginning of January, followed by a written text at the end of January, and give a presentation this week. I submitted the abstract, which my thesis director approved, after only doing some preliminary analysis which left a lot to be verified. Then due to some other urgent priorities and some other things a long the way, I didn't get down to writing the paper until a week before it was due. I pulled myself together and wrote a complete paper in about a week, and submitted it, without my thesis director checking it (there wasn't time, but I did have some discussions with the post-doc on our project, so I knew my work had some merit). But I wasn't satisfied with the quality of my work. Fast forward to last week and it was time to prepare a presentation. Turns out that I had found some interesting, but complex, results and my colleague and I spent a long time trying to understand what was going on. I put the presentation together and sent it to my thesis director with lots of time for him to check it. On Wednesday we met to discuss it, and he wasn't sure - he raised some very valid concerns that were justifiable, but also gave me a lot of good suggestions on how to improve the presentation. This lead me to completely redoing all the analysis for the presentation (this was my idea), and reworking the entire thing to get it done by Thursday night. The reworked version was better, but in my mind, still not complete and left a lot of questions unanswered. This morning I put together some notes and went over the presentation once before actually delivering it.
It went really well, and was really well-received, and I was surprised. Both experts offered some very helpful suggestions and some constructive criticism (thankfully at aspects that I already knew were lacking), but they both also complimented the quality of the work (hehe - if only they knew the journey!). One expert even went so far as to say that with only a little more work the paper is ready for submission to a journal!
My thesis director and I had a long discussion afterwards - he too offered some compliments, and then we launched into a long discussion about what the next steps are (in French of course!). This work really developed out of my ideas, and it is really something that I feel is "my research" - and I am challenged by it, but also excited. In the words of my thesis director today, "this is something new and different, but also very complex without a clear path, and you are making your way" - and I was really touched by his confidence in me.
I sincerely hope this post doesn't come across as arrogant, because that is not my heart. But I think I realized some important things this week...
1) Sometimes it is OK to rely on the confidence other people have in you, even when you may be lacking in self-confidence
2) I am so incredibly grateful for the team I work in - my thesis director and the post-doc on our project are so experienced and knowledgeable, and they are always willing to give their time to me - I learn something new from them all the time
3) I am not going to get it right the first time, but the act of taking another look at something gives me the occasion to stay humble, to broaden my horizons, discover new things, and make things better
4) I am really where I am meant to be at the moment - yes I sometimes have doubts, but I actually well and truly know that is exactly what I should be at the moment, and for this I am grateful.
5) And finally, I don't underestimate the provision, favour and grace of God in all of this - He was with me this week, and He ordained my steps and guided my thinking. He closed the gap between my efforts (or lack thereof) and the result. As my devotional very appropriately said this morning:
"Give yourself gully to the adventure of today. Walk boldly along the path of Life, relying on your ever-present Companion. You have every reason to be confident, because My Presence accompanies you all the days of your life"(Jesus Calling, S. Young)